For the Database Searching competency, I began with a
Building Block search of the ERIC database. I defined my search terms as follows.
S1 = (early reader or child* or you??)
S2 = (engage or interest or absorb or participat* or occupy)
S3 = (public or regional or branch) AND librar*
Search Strategy: S1 AND S2 AND S3
Results: 515 hits
Top 3 (sorted by relevance):
1. Spielberger, Julie, Carol Horton, Lisa Michels, and Robert Halpern. 2004.
New on the shelf: Teens in the library. Findings from the evaluation of public libraries as partners in youth development, an initiative of the Wallace Foundation. Final report. Chicago: Chapin Hall
Center for Children, University of Chicago.
2. Zerby, Marilyn C. 1992. The use of children's library services by child care givers in the
Norweld service area. MLS Research Paper, Kent State University.
3. Fronius, Sandra K. 1993. Reading interests of young adults in Medina County, Ohio. MLS
Research Paper, Kent State University.
Because this search provided a number of hits that are not related to my search topic, and it found too many records to sort efficiently, I first tried adding (NOT teen) to my search, but that left 485 hits. So next, I used the Thesaurus to find preferred terms for my search. I ended up searching ((DE "Children" and DE "Childrens Literature") and (DE "Public Libraries")) and (DE "Library Services"), which gave me 21 hits. Sorted by relevance, the top 3 hits follow.
1. Gallivan, Marion VanOrsdale, and Washington, DC. ERIC Clearinghouse on Library and
Information Sciences. 1973.
Research on Children's Services in Libraries. An Annotated Bibliography.
2. Tretheway, Willeen, Madison. Div. of Library Services. Wisconsin State Dept. of Public
Instruction, and And Others. 1974.
Kid Stuff-Again; A Catalog of Materials for Children's Programs in Public Libraries.
3. Weir, Sandra, and Springfield, Illinois State Library. 1975. Administration of children's
services.
Illinois Libraries 57, no. 1: 68 pp.
These actually look like pretty useful articles, and the number of results is manageable to sort. The Building Block search strategy seems effective, when used correctly with the database. Once I utilized the Thesaurus, I had more appropriate results than when I used natural language. If I was using a database without a Thesaurus, though, I would have to manage with a natural language search and hope that items were tagged better.
For the
Specific Facet First search, I searched the Academic Search Complete (ASC) database. I chose public libraries as the most specific facet. I noticed after a first quick try that I would need to be sure to search in Subject, to exclude records just from the author name (i.e. Young) or journal title (anything with library or libraries). To check this, I tried the following searches. The first hit (when sorted by relevance) for each is listed directly below it.
S1 = (public or branch or regional) AND librar* = 12,587 hits
1. New York City libraries brace for massive cuts. 1991.
American Libraries 22, no. 1: 6-7.
S2 = (engage or invite or occupy or engross or interest) = 20,635
1. Zytowski, Donald G. 1992. Three generations: The continuing evolution of Frederic Kuder's
interest inventories.
Journal of Counseling & Development 71, no. 2: 245-248.
S3 = (early reader or child* or you??) = 353,768
1. Dale, Nan, Roman Danko, and Markhant Breen. 2001. Confronting adolescent bias and
intolerance through cross-cultural immersion: An American-Croatian collaboration."
Child Welfare 80, no. 5: 623-630.
None of the first few hits in any of the searches looked particularly promising. Clearly, I need to go back and work with one of the other search strategies or a different database. When I narrowed it down by searching all three facets, I got only 4 results, but none of them appeared to really touch on what I was looking for, and it was too few.
Next, I tried the
Successive Fractions search, this time in LibLit. Note: I began with the search "All - SmartSearch," but got far too many results. I decided again to search by subject to retrieve more appropriate results. Since the early reader facet appeared the broadest based on last time, I decided to try that one to start with this time. I was proven wrong, with the following results - again with the first hit listed under each:
S1: early readers or children or youth - searched as (early reader or child* or you??) = 20,798 hits
1. Prater, Mary Anne and Tina Taylor Dyches. 2008.
Teaching about disabilities through children's literature. Westport: Libraries Unlimited.
S2: (engage or invite or absorb or engross or interest or participate) = 1,200 hits
1. Lenz, Connie and Helen Wohl. 2008. Does form follow function? Academic law libraries' organizational structures for collection development.
Law Library Journal 100 no. 1: 59-116.
S3: (public or regional or branch) AND librar* = 24,458 hits
1. Brehm-Heeger, Paula. 2008.
Serving urban teens. Westport: Libraries Unlimited.
S3 and S1 = 1,284 hits
1. Brehm-Heeger, Paula. 2008. Serving urban teens. Westport: Libraries Unlimited.
S3 and S1 and S2 = 3 hits
1. McKearney, Miranda. 2000. Deserved recognition well overdue.
Public Library Journal 15, no. 4: 120-122.
The jump by adding S2 was great, and narrowed down my results too far. In fact, the three articles that came up all talked about the same reading program in Great Britain. I obviously need to look at my terminology to be more successful in my searching. I tried adding (or activit* or program) to S2, and I got 234 records. I noticed, though, that teens were coming up in the first few hits, so I added NOT (teen* or adult) (in All - SmartSearch again) to my search. I got 114 hits, which is at least more manageable. It still seems like this strategy with this database needs some more work, or is simply not the right choice for my topic.
Finally, I tried the
Citation Pearl Growing search in Books in Print (BIP). I found the book Managing Children's Services in the Public Library, by Adele Fasick and Leslie Holt. I clicked on Bowker Subject CHILDREN'S LIBRARIES to try to find similar titles, which gave me 227 results. Sorted by date (default), the Fasick book was number 13. When I sorted by relevance, it was not even on the first page of 25. I was glad to find a few books that seemed even more appropriate to my topic, though, including the following:
Book Bridges: Story-Inspired Activities for Children Three Through Eight, by Terry J. Moore and Anita B. Hampton
Children Selecting Books in a Library, by Kara Reuter
Multimedia Approach to Children's Literature, edited by Mary Alice Hunt (published by ALA)
A Place for Children: Public Libraries as a Major Force in Children's Reading, edited by Judith Elkin
Read for the Fun of It: Active Programming with Books for Children, by Caroline Feller Bauer
Something Musical Happened at the Library: Adding Song and Dance to Children's Story Programs, by Rob Reid
The Storytime Handbook, by Deb Tuma-Church
Overall, I felt like this search in this database was productive, as it gave me a number of titles that sound very promising for my topic. I think I could get a lot of good ideas on how to engage young children in public libraries from these titles, among others on my result list.